12428 vs 12458 — Compare ZIP Codes
Side-by-side comparison. Blue = ZIP 12428, Orange = ZIP 12458.
Quick verdict: ZIP 12428 is wealthier, more affordable rent, more educated, higher work-from-home share. ZIP 12458 is higher home values, lower poverty rate, lower unemployment, more diverse.
Quick Facts
ZIP 12428
Ellenville village, NY
View full profile →- Population6,972
- Median Income$78,802
- Median Home Value$201k
- Median Rent$811
- Median Age43.5 yrs
- Poverty Rate20.6%
ZIP 12458
Napanoch CDP, NY
View full profile →- Population3,195
- Median Income$65,547
- Median Home Value$206k
- Median Rent$1,583
- Median Age49.0 yrs
- Poverty Rate8.0%
Visual comparison (same scale)
Population
6,9723,195
Median Income
$78,802$65,547
Median Home Value
$201k$206k
Median Rent
$811$1,583
Median Age
43.5 yrs49.0 yrs
Poverty Rate
20.6%8.0%
Demographics
ZIP 12428
Ellenville village, NY
View full profile →- White %75.7%
- Black %4.2%
- Asian %0.7%
- Hispanic %28.3%
- Age 0–17 %19.9%
- Age 18–64 %57.1%
- Age 65+ %23.1%
- Bachelor's+ %25.6%
- Diversity Index35/100
ZIP 12458
Napanoch CDP, NY
View full profile →- White %57.6%
- Black %21.3%
- Asian %0.0%
- Hispanic %22.1%
- Age 0–17 %5.8%
- Age 18–64 %74.5%
- Age 65+ %19.7%
- Bachelor's+ %9.4%
- Diversity Index57/100
Visual comparison (same scale)
White %
75.7%57.6%
Black %
4.2%21.3%
Asian %
0.7%0.0%
Hispanic %
28.3%22.1%
Age 0–17 %
19.9%5.8%
Age 18–64 %
57.1%74.5%
Age 65+ %
23.1%19.7%
Bachelor's+ %
25.6%9.4%
Diversity Index
35/10057/100
Economy
ZIP 12428
Ellenville village, NY
View full profile →- Median Income$78,802
- Unemployment %6.9%
- IRS Net Migration+301
- Work From Home %9.9%
ZIP 12458
Napanoch CDP, NY
View full profile →- Median Income$65,547
- Unemployment %4.3%
- IRS Net Migration+138
- Work From Home %5.6%
Visual comparison (same scale)
Median Income
$78,802$65,547
Unemployment %
6.9%4.3%
IRS Net Migration
+301+138
Work From Home %
9.9%5.6%
Housing
ZIP 12428
Ellenville village, NY
View full profile →- Median Home Value$201k
- Median Rent$811
- Owner Occupied %62.1%
- Broadband %82.3%
- Vacant %25.9%
- Median Year Built1956
ZIP 12458
Napanoch CDP, NY
View full profile →- Median Home Value$206k
- Median Rent$1,583
- Owner Occupied %83.8%
- Broadband %81.2%
- Vacant %13.0%
- Median Year Built1961
Visual comparison (same scale)
Median Home Value
$201k$206k
Median Rent
$811$1,583
Owner Occupied %
62.1%83.8%
Broadband %
82.3%81.2%
Vacant %
25.9%13.0%
Median Year Built
19561961
Climate & Location
ZIP 12428
Ellenville village, NY
View full profile →- Snow Days/Year0 days
- Elevation (ft)1,270 ft
- Nearest Airport24.9 miles (40.1 km)
- Distance to Coast25.1 miles (40.4 km)
ZIP 12458
Napanoch CDP, NY
View full profile →- Snow Days/Year0 days
- Elevation (ft)2,650 ft
- Nearest Airport27.6 miles (44.5 km)
- Distance to Coast21.7 miles (35.0 km)
Visual comparison (same scale)
Snow Days/Year
0 days0 days
Elevation (ft)
1,270 ft2,650 ft
Nearest Airport
24.9 miles (40.1 km)27.6 miles (44.5 km)
Distance to Coast
25.1 miles (40.4 km)21.7 miles (35.0 km)
Infrastructure
ZIP 12428
Ellenville village, NY
View full profile →- Work From Home %9.9%
- Walkability (0–100)48
- Broadband %82.3%
ZIP 12458
Napanoch CDP, NY
View full profile →- Work From Home %5.6%
- Walkability (0–100)27
- Broadband %81.2%
Visual comparison (same scale)
Work From Home %
9.9%5.6%
Walkability (0–100)
4827
Broadband %
82.3%81.2%
Frequently Asked Questions
How do ZIP 12428 and 12458 compare?
ZIP 12428 is wealthier, more affordable rent, more educated, higher work-from-home share. ZIP 12458 is higher home values, lower poverty rate, lower unemployment, more diverse.
What do the blue and orange colors mean?
Blue represents the first ZIP (12428), orange the second (12458). The same colors are used in the map markers and comparison bars.
Where does this data come from?
Data is from the U.S. Census Bureau and other federal sources. See our Methodology page for details.
How can I compare other ZIP codes?
From any ZIP page, use the "Compare with Another ZIP" tool, or go to /compare/XXXXX-vs-YYYYY (replace with two 5-digit ZIP codes).
Continue exploring